What the AFL's fixture difficulty number actually measures
The first thing to do with a fixture difficulty ranking is read its definition. Otherwise a useful observation about repeated opponents quickly becomes a much bigger claim about fairness, finals chances or favouritism. Those are different arguments, and the number cannot settle all of them.
The AFL's published 2027 analysis adds the 2026 finishing positions of the six opponents each club meets twice. Its score is therefore a summary of the additional exposure to those opponents. It is not a rating of every ground, every flight or every match-up across the season. Reading it properly starts with the repeated opponents rather than the headline order.
That is a sensible place to begin because repeats create an obvious difference between clubs. One extra meeting with an established contender is a different assignment from one extra meeting with a struggling side, at least when judged on what those teams have already achieved. The ranking makes that difference visible with a simple, reproducible method. Supporters can look at the six names and understand where the result comes from, instead of accepting an unexplained strength rating.
Why the score runs backwards
Low means hard because a high finish carries a small position number. A team finishing first contributes one; a team finishing eighteenth contributes eighteen. In a hypothetical example, replacing a repeated opponent that finished eighteenth with one that finished first would reduce the total by seventeen. The smaller sum would represent a tougher set of repeats under this method. That example explains the calculation; it does not describe an actual fixture alteration.
The arithmetic also reveals the model's central compromise. It treats the distance between first and second as one point, and the distance between seventeenth and eighteenth as one point. That is how positions work, but it does not establish that the underlying football gaps are equal. A narrow difference in a finishing position and a substantial difference in playing standard can receive the same numerical treatment.
There is another reason to avoid overreading the total: it contains no forecast. It does not say how many games a club should win, how likely it is to make finals or which repeated opponent will be dangerous when the return meeting arrives. Those questions need additional assumptions. The ranking is most helpful as the opening evidence in a conversation about the draw. It becomes misleading when it is used as the entire conversation.
Brisbane and Richmond show what the number can explain
Brisbane sits at the hard end of the AFL's measure with a total of 44. Richmond is at the other end with 75. The gap is meaningful within the stated method: the Tigers' repeated opponents collectively occupied lower finishing positions in 2026. It does not mean Richmond has been handed a particular number of wins, or that Brisbane has lost those wins before a ball is bounced.
| Club | Opponents played twice | Published score |
|---|---|---|
| Brisbane | Collingwood, Fremantle, Geelong, Gold Coast, St Kilda, Sydney | 44: hardest under this measure |
| Richmond | Adelaide, Collingwood, Essendon, North Melbourne, St Kilda, West Coast | 75: easiest under this measure |
Look past the different totals and two names immediately overlap: Collingwood and St Kilda. Both clubs have those return meetings. The contrast comes from the other four opponents in each set. This is a better way to discuss the draw than treating every Brisbane repeat as brutal and every Richmond repeat as gentle. The common opponents are a useful control. They make the specific source of the difference easier to see.
The numerical gap is 31 finishing-position points. Dividing that by six gives about 5.17 positions per repeated opponent. That calculation is a description of the two sets, not an estimate of scoring margin or ladder points. Keeping the unit attached to the number matters. A difference of 31 sounds dramatic, but it is very easy to accidentally talk about it as if it were a direct measure of football performance.
For a Brisbane supporter, the practical question is which of those return games creates the greatest challenge in its actual setting. Is a dangerous opponent met at home or away? Where does the match sit in the surrounding run? Is the side likely to face another strong opponent immediately afterwards? The list identifies the assignments worth inspecting. The club fixture pages then provide the sequence needed for that next step.
A Richmond supporter can make the same assessment without apologising for a favourable historical ranking or assuming it guarantees progress. A repeat against a side that finished lower can still become a difficult game. Improvement, regression and match-up problems do not wait for a published ranking to catch up. What the Tigers have received is a particular set of opponents, not a promise about how those opponents will play.
The strongest conclusion is therefore quite precise: Brisbane's additional exposure looks tougher when measured against the previous season's finishing order. Richmond's looks easier by that same yardstick. That finding deserves attention. It just needs to remain attached to its yardstick.
Three parts of a hard fixture that this ranking leaves out
Opponent strength is only one part of the assignment. A repeat-opponent score leaves out the place, the timing and the possibility that the opponent will change. These are not reasons to discard the number. They are reasons to use it alongside the fixture rather than in place of the fixture.
Where and when a rematch is played
The AFL's 2027 fixture statement provides a useful example. Fremantle hosts Brisbane at Optus Stadium on Sunday night in Round 8, while the return meeting is at the Gabba on Thursday night in Round 16. Both meetings involve the same two clubs. Their different settings do not change the repeat-opponent score, yet they plainly matter to how supporters and football departments read the schedule.
Venue changes the practical assignment: which team travels, which crowd attends and how the match fits around the club's other commitments. Timing supplies another layer. To assess recovery properly, identify the previous game, its actual start time, its location and the next assignment. Merely seeing “Thursday” or “Sunday” on one line cannot establish a scheduling advantage. A single match has to be read as part of a sequence.
That exercise becomes more limited late in the year. The league has fixed dates and start times for Rounds 1–16, while the final eight rounds have confirmed opponents and venues with floating dates and times. Supporters can assess those late opponents now, but some timing comparisons remain incomplete. A confident calculation that silently assigns an unconfirmed Friday or Sunday would add information the fixture has not yet supplied.
How much an opponent changes over summer
The historical ranking also holds every opponent still. Real teams do not stand still. A younger side might improve; an established contender might encounter a different set of availability problems; a change in personnel or roles might alter a difficult match-up. Those are possibilities to examine as evidence arrives, rather than reasons to write an invented ladder in November.
A useful way to read the score is as a baseline. Ask first what last year's finishing positions say. Then ask which assumptions would need to change for that picture to look different. If your argument depends on a particular opponent improving, explain why and acknowledge that you are making a forecast. Do not quietly replace a historical measure with a prediction and continue calling it the official ranking.
This distinction improves the football discussion. It allows a supporter to say the repeats look demanding on last season's evidence while reserving judgement about how demanding they will actually become. It also makes later assessment fairer: compare the original expectation with what happened, rather than pretending the result was obvious from fixture day. A model can be useful without being complete, provided its limits stay visible.
Gather Round and rivalry games complicate the fairness argument
A draw can pursue more than one worthwhile objective. Supporters want meaningful matches, recognisable rivalries, accessible venues and a fair competitive assignment. Those preferences do not always lead to the same fixture. A rivalry that people are eager to see again also becomes another repeated opponent that someone else does not receive.
That is why “everybody should play everybody” does not finish the argument about repeats. With eighteen clubs there are seventeen distinct opponents for each side. Once a club plays twenty-three home-and-away matches, six meetings go beyond a single game against each opponent. The question becomes how those additional meetings are distributed. Identifying that arithmetic does not prove any particular allocation is ideal, but it makes the choice being debated much clearer.
Gather Round adds another distinction between a fixture label and a football setting. The official 2027 announcement places all eighteen clubs in South Australia for Round 4, across Adelaide Oval, Norwood Oval and Barossa Park. Those matches belong to the season's schedule; they should not be casually counted as a second set of extra games on top of the repeated-opponent calculation.
The announcement also says its teams are listed alphabetically, with home and away allocations to be decided through a random selection process except for Adelaide and Port Adelaide, which are always the home teams. Reading the first name in that announcement as proof of a normal home assignment would therefore be a mistake. Even a confirmed administrative home label would not make a South Australian ground equivalent to a travelling club's usual home venue.
This matters when supporters compare home-ground access. An argument about the number of home labels and an argument about the number of games at a familiar stadium are not necessarily measuring the same thing. A fair comparison states which question it is answering. The same discipline should apply to travel: identify where the game actually takes place instead of inferring a journey from the order of club names.
Rivalry matches deserve a similarly careful reading. Their appeal explains why supporters value them, but popularity alone cannot establish that the resulting competitive distribution is balanced. Conversely, identifying a difficult rivalry repeat does not establish that the fixture has been designed to disadvantage a club. The worthwhile debate is about the consequences of a choice, the alternatives and the standards used to compare them.
For fans, that leaves room for a strong but measured position. Enjoy the matches the calendar produces, then inspect the competitive cost separately. A fixture can be commercially appealing and still contain an imbalance worth discussing. It can also contain an unavoidable trade-off without every disappointed club having been singled out.
How to make a stronger complaint about your club's draw
The best fixture complaints are specific enough to be tested. “Our repeats look strong on the previous season's finishing order” is one claim. “Our club has an awkward sequence of travel and recovery” is another. “Our supporters have fewer convenient times to attend” is a third. Each can be worth making, but they need different evidence. Combining them into one vague accusation makes a reasonable concern easier to dismiss.
Build a comparison rather than a conspiracy
Start by choosing the question. For repeat-opponent strength, list the six opponents and use one consistent finishing-order definition for every club. For travel, record the actual venues and sequence rather than simply counting away labels. For recovery, compare the same stretch of games and the same definition of a break. If one comparison includes a bye and another does not, explain that difference before presenting the result.
Next, keep the sample consistent. The full fixture coverage distinguishes the scheduled opening sixteen rounds from the floating final eight. A comparison of known Thursday and Friday slots should not be presented as a complete account of every possible late-season timeslot. Likewise, an account of the hardest opening month is not automatically an account of the hardest season.
Then identify a plausible alternative. If a supporter wants a particular repeat removed, another assignment has to take its place and the other clubs still need a workable draw. It is reasonable to ask whether a different allocation would reduce an imbalance. It is less useful to imagine only the benefit to one club while leaving every other fixture unchanged. A good alternative makes the cost of the trade-off visible too.
Finally, separate outcome from intent. A demonstrable disadvantage can exist without evidence of a deliberate attempt to produce it. Explaining that disadvantage clearly is more persuasive than asserting a motive that the available material cannot establish. The same standard should apply when your own club appears to benefit: describe the advantage, recognise the limits and resist turning it into a guarantee of success.
The 2027 ranking offers supporters a solid starting question: who must your club meet again? The more revealing follow-up is what those games look like in context. Use the AFL fixture for the assignments and the ladder for the competition as it develops. Keep the historical score as a reference point. The football will supply the evidence that a November table cannot yet provide.
Join the conversation
Share a question or a thought about AFL. Comments are reviewed before they appear. Keep it friendly and on topic.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Sign in with Google to leave a comment. Your email address is not displayed.